Discussion
questions for The Death of Ivan Illych
Work in a small group (2-3)
and write answers to the following questions on your own paper. Cite page
numbers for the passages that you cite in your answers. (Obviously, this means
that I expect you to cite passages in your answers). Remember
Claim/Support/Explanation (CSE)
“Ivan
Illych’s life had been most simple and most ordinary
and
therefore most terrible.”
- Reread the passage on page 19
beginning with “Peter Ivanovich sighed still
more deeply. . .” and ending with “signifying his full conviction that it
must indeed be so.” What is the tone of this passage and to what effect?
- What impression do you have of Praskovya Fedorovna? What is
the basis for your impression?
- Explain Ivan’s perception of
marriage.
- Ivan decorates the family’s new
house thinking he’s doing a wonderful job—quite pleased with the result.
But what does Tolstoy say is the actual effect? Can you compare this
situation to any that exist today, even to the type of house one might
prefer to own?
- Who came to and who was
excluded from Ivan’s parties?
- Comment on this passage from
page 40: “and Ivan Illych was left alone with
the consciousness that his life was poisoned and was poisoning the lives
of others, and that this poison did not weaken but penetrated more and
more deeply into his whole being.” What is Ivan thinking about? What does
this mean?
- Describe the relationship
between Ivan and Gerasim, his servant.
- What is “It?”
- At the beginning of part VI, Ivan
thinks that it “would be too terrible” if he were to die and gives
evidence that he is not simply a mortal man as Caius
in the old syllogism. What’s the purpose of this passage?
- The end of Ivan’s life is
consumed by helplessness, loneliness and pain. Tolstoy writes, “It seemed
to him that he and his pain were being thrust into a narrow, deep black
sack, but though they were pushed further and further in, they could not
be pushed to the bottom. And this, terrible enough in itself, was
accompanied by suffering.” This black sack is one of the main symbols in
the story. Again at the end of the story, he is in the sack again for
three days, screaming incessantly. But then, he is not. Reread the last
two pages of the story, beginning with “Suddenly some force struck him in
the chest. . . .”
- Answer these questions:
i.
“Ivan
Illych’s life had been most simple and most ordinary
and therefore most terrible.” What was most terrible?
ii.
What
is the joy?
iii.
What
does Tolstoy want us to know about our lives through our experiences with
Ivan’s life?